IN THE SUPREME COURT OF 3TJDICATURE OF JANAICA
IN COA/ZMON LAW 
SLJIT NO. C.L. 1994/N-102 
BETWEEN LLOYD NEEDHAM PLAINTIFF 
AWD ALICE SlOLVERA lSTD EFENDANT 
I AND VALENTINO SILVERA 2ND DEFENDANT 
Mr. Ainsworth Campbell for the Plaintiff.

Miss Racquel Dunbar instructed by McGlasl~an Robinson & Company for the
Defendant.
Heard on 20" Aoril2002.3rd hne 2002 and lath Seotember 2002
Csm~belJl.
The plaintiff commenced his action for negligence by Writ of Summons,
dated 16th March 1994.
*G (a) The plaintiffs case: -
-- On the 3rd September 1993, tlie plaintiff, a plumber, was on his way from
Comwall Agencies, on Spanish Town Road, where he had gone to collect a
cheque. The plaintiff testified .that it was about 2;30pm, He said he was riding at a
"normal speed", easterly, and very close to the sidewalk "a foot or less". When
something-hit him in his back, he lost consciousness, "until I came to know myself
again about 7 o'clock in the evening at Kingston Public Hospital." He denied that