The Hon. Mr. Justice Lennox Campbell

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF JUDICATURE OF JAMAICA

SUIT NO. 1998 E 556

BETWEEN CECIL PATRICK

AND BASIL SAMMS

AND EDNA ROBINSON

CLAIMANT

lSTD EFENDANT

2N" DEFENDANT

Ms. Althea McBean instructed by Frater, Ennis & Gordon for the defendants.

Heard: 31S' January 2006 and 27th July 2007

Campbell, J.

IN THE SUPRME COURT OF JUDICATURE OF JAMAICA

CLAIM NO. 2007 HCV 0 1 184

BETWEEN THE PARISH COLTNCIL OF MANCHESTER CLAIMANT

AND ANTOINETTE BOYNE DEFENDANT

Ms. Rose Bennett and Ms. Kemilee McClymont instructed by Bennett and Beecher-Bravo for

the claimant.

C Mr. Debeyo Adedipe for the defendant.

Heard: 7th and 8th May 2007

Injunction - S. 23 Town and Country Planning Act - Personal Nature of Injunction -

Balance of Convenience

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF JUDICATURE OF JAMAICA

CLAIM NO. CL 1996lM43

BETWEEN GLENTCIN MORRISON CLAIMANT

AND STEADMAN HENRY 1 ST DEFENDANT

AND NIGEL F AIRCLOUGH 2ND DEFENDANT

Jermaine Spence and Laurence Jones instructed by DunnCox for the

Claimant.

C' Donald Gittens for the 1" and 2nd Clefendants.

CLAIM NO. CL 1996lSl61 (Con~solidated)

\

BETWEEN EVELINIIO SMITH CLAIMANT

AND STEADMAN HENRY 1 ST DEFENDANT

AND GLENTCIN MORRISON 2ND DEFENDANT

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF JLJDICATURE OF JAMAICA

CLAIM NO. HCV 0063 712004

BETWEEN RAPHAEL LEWIS CLAIMANT

AND ATTORNEY GENERAL FOR JAMAICA DEFENDANT

Nelton Forsythe and Latoya Green instructed by Forsythe & Forsythe for Claimant.

Nicole Lambert and Kevin Powell instructed by Director of State Proceedings for Defendant.

C; Heard 27&, 28& Se~tember2 006 and 7& Se~tember2 007

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF JUDICATURE OF JAMAICA

CLAIM NO. E 400 of 2002

BETWEEN RICHARD LINDSAY DOWNER APPLICANT

AND ERICA ANNE DOWNER RESPONDENT

Derrek Jones and Maliaca Wong instructed by Myers Fletcher and Gordon for the applicant.

Pamela Benka-Coker, Q.C. instructed by Debra E. McDonald for the Respondent.

Heard isth, 16th,1 7 'a~n d isth July 2003,5'h, btha nd 7th~ ovember20 03. 1 6 '~a nuarv2 004, C': ,I 5th~ p r i2l0 04, 17'~i,s th, 19'~2,o tha nd 21StM av 2004,14'~,i sth and 1 6 'J~U N 20044,12th

IN THE SUPREME COUR'I' OF JUIIICATURE OF JAMAICA

CIVIL DIVISION

CLAIM NO. MCV 00229412006

BETWEEN JOY DOUGLAS 1' CLAIMANT

AND MARLENE DOUGLAS 2"D CLAIMANT

AND JACKLYN DOUGLAS 3RD CLAIMANT

AND IVAN DOIjGLAS 4T" CLAIMANT

AND BARCLAYS BANK PLC lSTD EFENDANT

AND NATIONAL COMMERCIAL

BANK JAMAICA LIMITED 2"D DEFENDANT

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF JUL)ICATURE OF JAMAICA

CLAIM NO. F.D. 1998/D053

BETWEEN DENNIS DARBY PETITIONER

AND JOYCE MARJORIE DARBY RESPONDENT

Ms. Gillian Mullings, instructed by Patrick Ba-iley and Co. for the Petitioner.

Mrs. P. Benka-Coker, instructed by Mi. Carol Vassal1 for the Respondent.

Campbell J.

(1) The parties were married on the iith September 1946, Mr. Darby was then aged

22 years old and Mrs. Darby, 18 years. Almost fifty-two years later the husband

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF JUDICATURE OF JAMAICA

CLAIM NO. 2000/M-012

BETWEEN ANGELLA MOORE CLAIMANT

A N D EDWARD TATE 1ST DEFENDANT

A N D DALBERT MCDONALD 2ND DEFENDANT

Ms. Suzette Wolfe and Ms. Celia Barclay instructed by Crafton S. Miller and Co.

for the claimant.

Mr. Ian Robins instructed by Tenn Russell Chin Sang Hamilton and Ramsay for the

defendant.

Heard 16th, 17th and 18th April 2008

Campbell, J.

1. On the 9th November 1997, the claimant, a cashier at a New Kingston

Constitutionality of legislation – Whether section 20 of the Independent Commission of Investigations (INDECOM) Act is unconstitutional – Effect of section 20 conferring on the Commissioner and investigative staff of INDECOM, in the exercise of their duty, like powers, authorities and privileges as are given by law to a constable – Whether INDECOM’s officers have the powers of arrest and charge – Whether INDECOM’s officers having such powers would undermine the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions