IN THE SUPREME COURT OF JUDICATURE OF JAMAICA

IN COMMON LAW

SUIT C.L. NO. S-089 of 1998

BETWEEN CARLOS STUPART 1st CLAIMANT

AND COPELAND STUPART 2nd CLAIMANT

AND THE ATTORNEY GENERAL 1st DEFENDANT

AND DETECTIVE JOHN DAVIS 2nd DEFENDANT

Huntley Watson instructed by

Watson & Watson for Claimants

Miss Julie Thompson and Bryan Moodie instructed by the

Director of State Proceedings for the Defendants.

Heard: 6th January, 2006,7th February, 2006

& July 20,2007.

MARSH J.

The Claimants' Statement of Claim is phrased:-

The Claimants are brothers. First Claimant Carlos Stupart is an auto body

repairman who also buys, repairs and sells used and wrecked automobiles from a

location at Salt Marsh in the parish of Trelawny.

The Second Claimant Copeland Stupart is a University lecturer and resides

in the parish of St. Catherine.