Evanscourt Estate Co. Ltd v National Commercial Bank Ja Ltd., etal

IN 'THE SUPREME COURT OF JUDICATURE OF JAMAICA

IN THE CIVIL DIVISION

CLAIM NO E-013 OF 2000

BETWEEN EVANSCOllRT ESTATE

COMPANY LIMITED

(By Original Action)

AND NATIONAL COMMERCIAL BANK

JAMAICA LIMITED

(By Original Action)

AND

CLAIMANT

DEFENDANT

BETWEEN NATIONAL COMMERCIAL BANK

JAMAICA LIMITED CLAIMANT

AND EVANSCOURT ESTATE

COMPANY LIMITED

AND DESIGN MATRIX LIMITED 2"DEFENDANT

(By way of Counterclaim and Set Off)

Paul Beswick instructed by Beswick and Ballentyne for the Claimant in the original action and for

the 1st Defendant in the second action

Sandra Minott Phillips instructed by Myers Fletcher and Gordon for the Defendant in the original

action and for the Claimant in the second action

Charles Piper for the 2nd Defendant by way of Counterclaim and Set Off

HEARD: October 26, and November 1,2007

REASONS FOR DECISION