A world-class judiciary utilizing innovation and technology for efficient service delivery.


To provide sound, timely judgments and efficient court services in an environment where all stakeholders are valued.

City Properties Limited v New Era Finance Limited

Case Number: 
2013 CD 00166
Neutral Citation: 
[2016]JMCC Comm. 1
Date of Delivery: 

Landlord and tenant - Agreement for a lease - Draft lease not executed as some terms were found objectionable by the tenant - Parties operating under the agreed terms of the draft lease - Claim by lessor for rent and outstanding maintenance - Whether maintenance properly charged to the tenant as additional rent - Whether tenant obliged to pay insurance and depreciation on the building as a component of maintenance

Civil procedure and practice - Pleadings - Counter claim for refund of monies inappropriately charged for maintenance - Claim made in witness statements and submissions for refund of overpayment on rent - No corresponding claim for overpayment made - Whether overpayment recoverable - Claim for damages for compensation for expenditure on chattels after destruction by fire - No basis shown for the claim - Negligence and occupiers liability not specifically pleaded - Declaration sought for parties to be declared joint occupiers - No basis shown for such a declaration - Whether there is sufficient evidence to ground a cause of action in damages for negligence or occupiers liability or for a claim for compensation for fire damage

 Evidence - Expert evidence - No permission sought by defendant at case management to rely on expert evidence - Quantity surveyor called at trial to give evidence of costs of materials and labour - Whether evidence given by quantity surveyor factual evidence and admissible as such - Whether evidence inadmissible as hearsay - Applicability of the Civil Procedure Rules 2000, part 32 and section 31G and of the Evidence Act


Emergency Matters

Emergency Matters

Matrimonial Proceedings

Customer Service

customer complaints image

Strategic Plan

Strategic Plan for the Jamaican Judiciary 2024-2028