Rural Transit Association Limited v Jamaica Urban Transit Company Limited et al

Case Number: 
2014 HCV02278
Neutral Citation: 
[2014] JMSC Civ. 143
Date of Delivery: 
29.09.2014

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF JUDICATURE
THE CIVIL DIVISION
CLAIM NO. 2014 HCV02278
BETWEEN RURAL TRANSIT ASSOCIATION LIMITED APPLICANT
AND JAMAICA URBAN TRANSIT COMPANY LIMITED 1st RESPONDENT
AND COMMISSIONER OF POLICE 2nd RESPONDENT
AND OFFICE OF UTILITIES REGULATION 3rd RESPONDENT
IN CHAMBERS
Mr. Hugh Wildman and Ms. Keiva Marshall, instructed by Hugh Wildman & Co. for the Applicant.
Mr. Walter H. Scott, Q.C. and Mr. Matthieu Beckford instructed by Rattary Patterson Rattary for the 1st Respondent.
Miss. Carlene Larmond instructed by Director of State Proceedings for the 2nd Respondent.
Mr. Allan S. Wood, Q.C and Mrs. Daniella R. Gentles-Silvera instructed by Livingston, Alexander Levy for the 3rd Respondent.
Heard: 1st July 2014, 3rdJuly 2014 & 29th September 2014.
Judicial Review – Application for leave to apply for Judicial Review – Sufficient interest to seek leave for Judicial Review – No identification of decision-maker to make determination of whether or not the decision making process was unlawful – Whether JUTC is amenable to Judicial Review – Whether OUR is the sole regulator of public transportation – Application for Prerogative writs refused – Application for Injunctive relief refused –No leave needed for Declaratory relief – Application for leave in respect of constitutional relief granted.

Customer Service

customer complaints image